 |
| The Pacifica Quartet (photo: Anthony Parmalee) |
“A thing that really surprised us about the cycle – we
hadn't played them all until we took [the project] on two years ago – was just
how interesting all of the quartets are”, Masumi Per Rostad, violist of the
Pacifica Quartet, tells me when I meet him at Wigmore Hall's spacious greenroom.
“It thought there would be at least one or two duds in there, from a
performance perspective, but I think it's very similar to the Beethoven cycle
in that regard, that they're all amazing pieces.”
I wonder about the challenges of presenting these works
together: might they present too little contrast over the course of a concert,
particularly when it comes to the later quartets? Not so, Masumi tells me: “I think that from
nine through fourteen there's actually a lot of range of character and emotion.
It's very easy to think of Shostakovich as bleak and desolate and Siberian and
I think that the thing has surprised us about all the quartets is how much
range there is.”
And then there's the problem of extra-musical baggage
attached to so much of Shostakovich's music. A great deal of argument about the
music has focused on supposed hidden meanings, political messages and personal
codes written into the scores. But are the players affected by these theories
and hearsay? “There's a difference when
between when one person reads it somewhere versus when someone reads it and
mention sit in a rehearsal. It does definitely affect us but it’s kind of a
tenuous area to get into, also because so much of what he said is hard to take
at face value.” Masumi reminds me that
the quartet are musicians, rather than musicologists, and recalls his
experience of studying Beethoven as a student at New York's Juilliard School:
“The only thing allowed into the classroom was the score for the string
quartets, and you could not mention anything about the Heiligenstadt Testament
or anything about deafness. It was just not allowed. It was just the score; I
think that's ultimately what Shostakovich left for us – the score – and there
are so many interesting stories... but at the end of the day it's us in the
rehearsal room with the score.”
Although Shostakovich himself trained as a pianist, he
had an acute understanding of writing for stringed instruments. “There's
nothing in the quartets that is unplayable,” says Masumi. “Within your
individual parts they're not crazily technically difficult but it requires a
lot of ensemble technique. There's a lot of exposed intonation, a lot of
Haydn-like exposed ensemble issues and I think that's probably for us the most
challenging aspect; but he really knows what works.”
Shostakovich composed for some of the finest
instrumentalists of his day and remained loyal to particular chamber ensembles
for years. The Pacifica Quartet have, in turn, engaged extensively with
contemporary composers, particularly when working with student composers at the
University of Chicago. “There's nothing like sitting down with a composer and
having them remind you that they’re human beings. As a student you’re working
through your repertoire and you feel very disconnected from the composer and
from the compositional process because you have this score that you get from a
library or a bookstore and somehow there’s so many layers or steps in between
you and that compositional process. The thing that has been in common with all
the composers that we’ve worked with is that they really are human beings and
they’re not so uptight. We’re not very often getting comments like ‘that wasn’t
quite together’, but it’s more like ‘I was going for this sound world'.”
Working through new works with musicians can also give
composers an understanding of what's technically possible, though this can have
its pitfalls. “This is always dangerous territory because if you look at the
history of performance and composition, pieces were always declared unplayable
and then the next group of people come along and they can play them. You don’t
want to be that guy that says ‘you know this is unplayable’, but you can say
‘maybe this is not the most idiomatic thing!'”
Recent works by Carter and Easley Blackwood have joined
Shostakovich and Mendelssohn in the Pacifica Quartet's discography, but it
would be a mistake to assume that merely the novelty of the new and unplayed
was what attracted them to their more unusual repertoire. “We have a common
idea that there’s great music and there’s less good music and it’s not defined
so much by period or genre. It's just that there are pieces that speak to us
when we play [them] and sometimes those are off the beaten path and very often
they’re in the standard repertoire, so it’s kind of a really wide variety and
mix just because we don’t really distinguish that way.”
Volume 3 of the Pacifica Quartet's Shostakovich String Quartety cycle is out now.
Volume 3 of the Pacifica Quartet's Shostakovich String Quartety cycle is out now.
